A Jewish Believer Who Found Jesus

By   •   April 8, 2013

Marty Goetz is a Messianic musician who grew up in the Jewish faith and later accepted Jesus Christ as the Messiah. Goetz is a featured performer at The Cove in Asheville, N.C., where he has several events coming up this year.

When Marty Goetz was growing up in a suburb of Cleveland, Ohio, in the 1950s, his life was steeped in Jewish culture.

“It was like little Israel,” said Goetz. “Almost all the people in my school and all the people with whom we associated were Jewish.”

No one would have dreamed the shy Jewish boy from Beachwood would one day compose melodies set to Scripture, praising Jesus Christ as the Jewish Messiah.

Bitten by the Show Biz Bug

As a boy, Goetz learned Hebrew, read the Torah, and sang the liturgy at his family’s synagogue. In 1970, he enrolled at Carnegie Mellon University in Pittsburgh, Pa., where he pursued a growing interest in the performing arts.

“That’s where I got into show business, and once I got bit by the show biz bug, that was it,” said Goetz.

He teamed up with another young musician named Bert, and the two aspiring performers took off for New York City.

In New York, Bert became a born-again Christian, and Goetz didn’t like it.

“I just wanted to get as far away from him as I could, because I couldn’t stand the whole Jesus thing,” said Goetz.

The act broke up, but Goetz couldn’t stop thinking about the increasing number of Christians who seemed to be popping up in his life.

Finding Jesus in L.A.

A short time late, Goetz left the Big Apple for Los Angeles. It was on his journey west that he discovered an unlikely item that would change his life.

“When I was on my way to California, I went through Cleveland and visited my parents. They had, for some reason, a big family Bible,” said Goetz. “They didn’t even realize they had it.”

Despite his distrust of Christianity, curiosity got the best of him.

“I picked up that Bible, stuffed it in a knapsack, and took it to L.A. with me, and I started reading it.”
It was around that time when Goetz began to notice something unusual.

“Things started happening around me that made me just start looking up,” he said. “I thought, ‘Somebody seems to be taking care of me here.’”

Confused but intrigued, Goetz turned to the Bible for answers. He wanted to figure out whether Jesus could ever fit into his Jewish life.

“If He was going to be my Lord, He had to be the Jewish Messiah,” said Goetz. “Then I started to read the first lines in Matthew, that He was the Son of David and the Son of Abraham.”

As he read Jesus’ words in the Gospels, his heart began to soften.

“I started to think, what do I have against this person?” said Goetz. “And the more I read about Him, the more I liked Him.”

Then, a good friend introduced him to a church called The Vineyard.

“At the end of the sermon, the pastor gave a beautiful invitation,” said Goetz. “He asked for whoever wanted to receive Jesus, and I walked up. That began my walk with the Lord.”

Love and Marriage

Still bitten by the show biz bug, the first thing Goetz did after becoming a believer was audition for a show about the Bible. Hoping to play the part of Jesus, he ended up with the role of “donkey owner.”

“I guess you can’t have everything,” laughed Goetz.

Bigger and better opportunities were around the corner. Goetz was chosen to play piano for recording artist Debby Boone. Thus began a new foray into the world of show business.

While attending a wedding in California, Goetz met a beautiful woman named Jennifer Yaffee. Just like him, Yaffee was Jewish and had come to believe in Jesus Christ as the Messiah. Goetz was smitten.

He married Yaffee in 1984, and they had a daughter, Danyel Misha. Jennifer became her husband’s manager, producer, and booking agent. Twenty-eight years later, she still manages Goetz’s career.

“I couldn’t do it without Jennifer,” said Goetz. “Besides putting up with me, she’s my biggest encourager.”

Meeting the Grahams

In 1991, Goetz’s musical talent led him to his first encounter with Billy Graham, who was speaking at an outreach event in New York City. Goetz performed his Messianic music, representing the Jewish believers of New York.

Three years later, Goetz found himself with Billy Graham once again, this time at The Cove in Asheville, N.C. There, Goetz met Mr. Graham and his late wife, Ruth.

“He of course is known for his humility,” said Goetz. “It wasn’t like talking to Billy Graham at all; it was just like talking to a brother. He seemed just as happy to meet you as you were thrilled to meet him.”

Goetz also had an encounter with Ruth Graham just outside the dining hall.

“I was eating, and I have a bit of a sweet tooth, so I grabbed a couple of brownies,” said Goetz. “After I had eaten dessert I took a couple extras and put them in a napkin.”

He was on the way back to his room, hidden brownies in hand, when he bumped into Mrs. Graham.
“I said, ‘Excuse me,’ and she just smiled,” said Goetz.

“The next day I was getting ready to lead worship in the chapel, and somebody walks in and puts a little box of baggies on my piano with a little note written by Mrs. Graham. It said something to the effect of, ‘Now you won’t have to sneak brownies out in napkins.’”

Still Singing

Goetz continues to be a favorite at The Cove, nearly two decades after his first visit.

The shy, Jewish boy from Ohio is making his mark on the Christian world by using his voice to praise his Savior, Jesus Christ.

Goetz’s Messianic music has been compared to the sweeping melodies of Broadway, but Goetz has a different way of describing his unique style.

“In the modern day, if there were such a thing as a psalmist, that’s what I would be,” said Goetz. “I’m a singer of psalms.”


Upcoming Events: You can hear Marty Goetz at six different Cove events this year, including the SeniorCelebration with Cliff Barrows and Friends on April 15-17 and the Women’s Spring Luncheon with Kendra Graham on April 18. Click here for a full list of Marty Goetz events, including his Christmas at the Cove concert.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published but you will receive our next BGEA ministry update. You can opt out of future emails at any time.


  1. Daisy Hobson says:

    I have met Marty, Jennifer, and Misha Goetz frequently as they ministered powerfully at my congregation in North Jersey, Beth Israel, Jonathan Cahn, Rabbi. My heart’s desire is for churches to understand Romans 1:16 and learn how to reach out to Jewish people. I have a cover letter, job resume and spiritual resume ready to send to BGEA to become involved in Jewish evangelism. To whom can I send it?

  2. Natalie durr says:

    I love your music!! Your rendition of “O Lord, Our Lord” is lovely and the bit of piano in it makes it so different and special! Thank you for the blessing that your music is!