Do Christians and Muslims Worship the Same God?

By Albert Mohler   •   December 1, 2013   •   Topics:

Christians and Muslims

Does God care what we call Him? Do Muslims and Christians worship the same god? These are questions many Christians are asking these days, and for good reason.

For some time now, feminist theologians and a host of others have suggested that Christians should adopt new names for God. One denomination went so far as to affirm names like “Giver, Gift and Giving” in place of the “Father, Son and Holy Spirit” to be used in worship. Feminist theologians have demanded that masculine pronouns and names for God be replaced with female or gender-neutral terms. But to change the name of God is to redefine the God we reference. Changing the name of God is no small matter.

As a matter of fact, God takes His name very seriously, and the Ten Commandments include the command that we must not take the name of the Lord in vain. We are to use the names God has given for Himself, and we are to recognize that God takes His name seriously because He desires to be rightly known by His human creatures. We cannot truly know Him if we do not even know His name.

Moses understood this. When he encountered the call of God that came from the burning bush, Moses asked God, “If I come to the people of Israel and say to them, ‘The God of your fathers has sent me to you,’ and they ask me, ‘What is his name?’ what shall I say to them?” (Exodus 3:13). God answered Moses, “I Am who I Am” (Exodus 3:14). God told Moses, “Say this to the people of Israel, ‘The Lord, the God of your fathers, the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob, has sent me to you.’ This is my name forever, and thus I am to be remembered throughout all generations” (Exodus 3:15).

As these verses make clear, we are not to tamper with God’s name. We are to use the names whereby God has named Himself, and we are to recognize that any confusion about the name of God will lead to confusion about the nature of God, if not to idolatry.

Christians must keep this central principle from the Bible constantly in mind as we consider some of the most urgent questions we face in the world today. We must certainly have this principle in mind when we think about Islam.

Several years ago, a bishop in the Netherlands attracted controversy when he argued that Christians should call God “Allah” in order to lower theological tensions. He also argued that calling God “Allah” would be commonplace in Christian churches within a century and that this would lead to a synthesis of Islam and Christianity.

More recently, an Islamic court in Malaysia ruled that only Muslims can use the name “Allah” in print publications. “The usage of the word will cause confusion in the community,” the chief judge ruled. Oddly enough, Christians may well agree with this Islamic judge. To call God “Allah” is to invite confusion.

In the Bible, God reveals Himself to us in many names. These names are His personal property. We did not invent these names for God. To the contrary, God revealed these names as His own.

We have no right to modify or to revise these names—much less to reject them. Jesus Christ made this abundantly clear. In the simplest way imaginable, Jesus teaches us to know God as Father, and to use this name in prayer. The Lord’s Prayer begins with the words, “Our Father, who is in heaven.” By the grace that God has shown us in Christ, we can truly know Him as Father.

Muslims do not speak of God as their heavenly Father. In the Islamic faith, Allah is not only a different name for god; the deity it designates is far more impersonal than the God of the Bible. Father—the very name that Jesus gave us as the designated name for use in prayer—is a name that simply does not fit Allah as depicted in the Quran.

Furthermore, Muslims claim that Allah has no son. This represents a head-on collision between the God of the Bible and Allah. For, as the Bible makes clear, the one and only true God is most perfectly revealed as the Father of the Son, Jesus Christ. In the Gospel of John, Jesus repeatedly teaches that no one has truly known the Father, except by the Son. In one of the most clarifying verses in the New Testament, Jesus declared Himself to be “the way, and the truth, and the life,” adding, “No one comes to the Father except through me” (John 14:6).

Because Muslims deny that God has a son, they explicitly reject any Trinitarian language. From the very starting point, Islam denies what Christianity takes as its central truth claim: the fact that Jesus Christ is the only begotten of the Father. If Allah has no son, then Allah is not the God who reveals Himself through the Son. How then can calling God “Allah” not lead to anything but confusion—and worse?

Islam teaches that the doctrine of the Trinity is blasphemous. But the Christian faith is essentially and irreducibly Trinitarian. The Bible reveals that the Father is God, that the Son is God, and that the Holy Spirit is God. Jesus is not merely a prophet, as acknowledged by Muslims, He is God in human flesh. This is precisely what Islam rejects.

The Trinitarian language is the language of the Bible, and it is essential to Christianity. Indeed, the Christian faith points to Christ and announces that we can only know the Father through the Son. Confusing the God of the Bible with Allah of the Quran is not only a mistake, it is a dangerous distortion of the Gospel of Christ.

The Trinitarian nature of God is embedded within the Great Commission. Jesus tells His disciples to go into the world and make disciples of all nations and to baptize them “in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit” (Matthew 28:19). Christians are those who bear the names of God even in our baptism, and those names are Father, Son and Holy Spirit.

This has become a matter of significant controversy in recent years as some Christians, including some serving with mission agencies, have argued that Christians can use the name “Allah” in talking about God. In some languages, especially those based on an Arabic source, there is no generic word for god. In such a situation, it might be necessary to begin a conversation by using this word, but the Christian cannot continue to call God “Allah.” It is hard to imagine that anyone can hear the name “Allah” without thinking of him as claimed in the Quran (see following article). Indeed, Muslims who speak languages other than Arabic use “Allah” as the name of god. But as soon as the Christian begins to explain that the true living God is the Father of Jesus Christ the Son, the Christian is making clear that the true living God is not Allah, but our Heavenly Father.

Continuing to use the name “Allah” to refer to the God of the Bible in such situations invites deep confusion. Some now argue that Muslims who come to faith in Christ can even remain within the mosque and continue to worship God as Allah. It is hard to see how that is anything other than a theological disaster.

We can now see that the name of God is no small matter. The deity we name is the God we believe in. Christians believe in only one God, and He is the Father who sent the Son to save us from our sins. Allah has no son, and, thus, Christians cannot know God as Allah. In this light, Muslims and Christians do not only use different names for God; in reality, these different names refer to different gods.

God takes His name with great seriousness, and so must we. Thankfully, we are not left in the dark, groping for adequate language. God has revealed His names to us, so that we can rightly know Him. We are not called to be clever or creative in referring to God, only faithful and accurate.

We are living in challenging days. One of the most pressing challenges of our times is the task of speaking rightly about God. This is particularly challenging when Christians encounter Muslims, but it is also a challenge when Christians encounter secular people in Western cultures. But this really isn’t a new challenge. It was the same challenge faced by the children of Israel as they encountered the Canaanites, and the same challenge faced by the Apostle Paul at Mars Hill.

Our challenge is to speak truthfully about God, and the only way we can do that is to use the names God gave Himself. The God of the Bible is not Allah, and Allah is not the God of the Bible. Any confusion about that undermines the very Gospel we preach.

©2013 R. Albert Mohler, Jr.

Scripture quotations are taken from the Holy Bible, English Standard Version.

R. Albert Mohler, Jr., is president of The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary, in Louisville, KY.

 

19 Comments

  1. Rick says:

    I wish the author would befriend a devout Muslim to see which parts of his opinion piece are false. Secondly I’d say look to the Bible rather than your southern roots for answers. Better theological answers can be found by googling theologians Dr. Tim Perry and Dr. Timothy George.

  2. Nat says:

    God the Father, God the Son (Jesus), and God the Spirit are all the true triune God. Allah of the Quran is not.
    HOWEVER…
    In Indonesia, where I live, the only word for “God” in our language, and in the Bible is Allah. It simply is the word for God. Our brothers and sisters in the Middle East use this word for God as well. God is pleased when His Name is worshipped in every language, be that Indonesian, Arabic, or English. His name is not spelled or pronounced just one way. Indeed that is the belief of the Muslims who believe that Arabic is the only language to be used to speak the word of God or invoke his name. However, Arabic Christians also speak Arabic and call Him, correctly, Allah. My Christian friends in Malaysia were very distressed that the radical Muslims insisted that only they could use the word Allah for God, because Allah is the word for God d in the Bible there. The author of this article has some good insights about the difference between Christian and Muslim theology, especially in regards to the trinity and the divinity of Christ, however, we need to u be careful not to throw the baby out with the bath water, so to speak.

  3. Leonard Turner says:

    This article by Albert Mohler , was well done. We as Christian must always hold to the Truth of God’s Word .

  4. Lian says:

    Wonderful insight. More clear on the fundamental difference in the 2 beliefs. Thanks to the writer.

  5. ODENIYI OLUWAFEMI says:

    ”A tree is known by its fruit”_Jesus Christ.

  6. Douglas Renton says:

    Almighty God of the Christian Bible has a Son, Jesus Christ.
    Allah of the Koran has no children – as any followers of Islam will tell you.
    The two, Almighty God and Allah, are therefore different………….!

  7. Indu Rai says:

    I would like to pay a lot of thanks to the writer.I was also confused in this subject.But today I have been completely convinced that there is difference between the god that Muslims worship and The God which we worship.so it should be known by the whole world.

  8. Hayward Johnson says:

    May God have mercy on those who are seeking his guidance and favor,and may they find that ever lasting peace that onley God can give them.

  9. John Panagiotidis says:

    Very well put! Often people confuse the true God with Alah arguing that “Alah realy means god” but, this god is NOT the God who created the universe, the earth and the people that have the liberty to think that way; the father of Jesus Christ is in his trinity nature: father-son-holy spirit the only God and Jesus the only name under heaven by which we may be saved.

  10. Lucy Elias-Simpson says:

    Brothers ? sisters. pray for those lost souls in the world………. sorry if I did made any mistakes in this email, my English isn’t very good , but trying my best ! God have mercy ………….

    1. jojin says:

      Thanks. I was making a big mistake. I thought allah and our father in heaven to be the same.
      Jesus The only True Living God.

Comments are closed.